|
Emptiness And Appearance Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoche, translated by Ari
Goldfield Excerpted from the transcript of "A Commentary
On What It Means To Be Lucky" (Vancouver 1998) Originally published in Bodhi
Issue 3 4 of
4 | 1, 2 , 3, 4
Eighth verse of Lucky:
Everything in samsara and nirvana, Without exception, is
neither one nor many So all phenomena are empty of
essence And knowing that, if you meditate on profound
emptiness Then you are so fortunate– This is what it means
to be lucky.
In the tradition of the hearers, the sravakas, and the
pratyekabuddhas, the solitary sages, the only aspect of emptiness
that is taught is the emptiness of the self, of the
individual. However, that is not the tradition of the great
vehicle. The great vehicle explains that everything, without
exception, in both samsara and nirvana, is empty of being either one
or many. Whatever it is, be it something in existence or something
involved with the state of enlightenment, everything is empty of any
inherent existence. Its existence transcends being either one thing
or many and, therefore, it does not truly exist. It has no
essence. It is like something that appears in a dream. It does
not truly exist. If we can know that and then meditate on profound
emptiness, that is what it means to be lucky.
Now, why is this adjective "profound" used in front of the word
"emptiness?" Because, if we do not listen to the teachings on
emptiness, and if we do not analyze them with reasoning, then there
is no way we can understand them. It is profound in that
way. It's not something that is accessible without applying
our intelligence towards trying to understand it. But if we
can actually meditate on this profound emptiness, meaning that we
use our intelligence and we listen to the teachings and we analyze
with reasoning, then we are fortunate. After first giving rise to
relative bodhicitta, then by meditating on the selflessness of the
individual as the basis, we meditate on the emptiness of all
phenomena. Through that process we can gain the enlightenment of the
Buddhas. Therefore, to be able to meditate on emptiness is something
that makes us incredibly fortunate, and that is what it means to be
lucky.
If we were to examine this from the perspective of logical
analysis, the object of our inquiry would be whatever we are looking
at, whatever we want to understand more about, whatever we are
focusing on in order to find out its true nature. In technical
terms, this can be called the object of inquiry or it can be called
the basis of inference. So the focus of our logical reasoning is
this object whose nature we are trying to discover. And, by
reason of the fact that it is neither one thing nor many things, we
can determine that it is of the nature of emptiness. It has no
existence. Therefore, we can create a logical reasoning, a seamless
reasoning, a flawless reasoning. The way we do that would be to say
that:
Given all of the phenomena in samsara and nirvana, all are
empty of inherent existence, because they are neither one nor
are they many. This proves to us that our object of inquiry is
empty of inherent existence.
We can also make a reasoning like this:
Given any and all of the suffering that we experience as
sentient beings, none of it really exists, because all of
it is neither one thing nor is it many one things.
An example is the suffering we experience in a dream. Why
is suffering neither one nor many? If we look at suffering, all the
past suffering is finished. It is completely gone. So
that suffering doesn't exist. The suffering of the future hasn't
happened yet. So that suffering doesn't exist either. What's left is
the suffering of the present. And if we try to find this
suffering of the present, what happens? We look, and we
find a smaller and smaller moment of it, as our analysis gets more
subtle. We try to find this precise moment of the present suffering,
and we just find smaller and smaller and smaller moments. In
our search, we can never find one truly existent indivisible moment
of suffering. Therefore suffering is not one indivisible thing, and
since you can't even find one thing, how could you have many things?
Therefore, suffering is neither one, nor is it many, and
consequently it is empty of any inherent existence.
We might, in response to this, advance the following type of
reasoning. We might say:
Suffering does too exist. Suffering is not beyond
being one or many. It really does exist, because I
experience it, because I experience it directly, manifestly.
But that's not a good reason. It does not follow that, just
because you experience suffering, the suffering is real. An
example is the suffering we experience in a dream. The
suffering we experience in a dream, however bad it might be, does
not exist really. It's neither one nor is it many. Even
though it looks like it's real, even though we think it's real, even
though we experience it, it does not really exist. So the fact that
it looks real, the fact that we are attached to it as being real,
and the fact that we experience it: none of these things prove that
it really exists. It's just a dream. Similarly, even though
our daytime experiences of suffering look and feel real to us, and
we are attached to their reality, this doesn't turn our suffering
into something real. It is not real.
Rinpoche has composed a verse to help us to understand this
easily. Rinpoche says that:
Because it is neither one nor many Anger does
not truly exist Just like the anger in a dream.
Because it transcends being one or many Desire does not
truly exist Just like the desire we experience in a
dream. Because it transcends being either one or many
Stupidity does not truly exist Just like stupidity in a
dream.
Because it transcends being one or many Pride does not
truly exist—pride has no self- nature Just like pride in a
dream. Because it transcends being one or many
Jealousy has no self-nature Just like jealousy in a
dream. Because it transcends being one or many Doubt
has no self-nature Just like doubt in a dream.
Because they transcend being either one or many Wrong
thoughts, bad thoughts, have no self-nature Just like bad
thoughts in a dream.
We need to know well how it is that kleshas have no inherent
existence. Then it will be easy for us to have kleshas or mental
afflictions, and be very relaxed and very open.
Ninth verse of Lucky:
Meditating on emptiness cuts the root of existence. Love and
compassion free you from the extreme of peace, of clinging to a
one-sided, static kind of peace that is only for one's own
benefit. The union of compassion and the wisdom realizing
emptiness results in the union of skillful means and wisdom in a way
that is stuck in neither the cycle of existence nor in a one-sided
selfish kind of peace. Bringing these two, wisdom and skillful
means, together in this way is a practice that makes us very
fortunate. If we can do that, that is what it means to be
lucky.
Tenth verse of Lucky:
The first step is to make the Mahayana path your sturdy base in
the way it has been explained in the verses above. It is the
base for the practice of Vajrayana because, before practicing the
Vajrayana, we must be able to bring together emptiness and
compassion. If we don't bring together the understanding of
emptiness and the practice of compassion before beginning the
practice of Vajrayana, then Vajrayana practice is a practice absent
of profundity. Vajrayana becomes a practice that lacks any
type of profundity. That's why the Mahayana practices of loving
kindness, compassion and emptiness must come first. Then, when we
begin to practice the Vajrayana, the basic view is that the totality
of appearance is the infinite expanse of purity. This means
that the vessel, the outer physical environment, is the immeasurable
palace, and the beings who live in this vessel are all deities, male
and female. When we know this very well, when we know it
correctly, when it is not just an opinion, but when we know that
this is the actual way things really are, then the four empowerments
(the vase empowerment, the secret empowerment, the wisdom
empowerment, and the word empowerment), which are the introduction
to the true nature of mind, will ripen our continuum. This is
the practice of profound creation and completion meditation. When we
practice these two stages, then this is what it means to be
lucky.
The verse speaks of profound creation and completion, so we could
ask the question, "Is there such a thing as creation and
completion practice that is not profound?" And the answer is: "Yes,
there is." If we meditate on merely the deity's form and
color, that is creation stage practice that is not profound.
Also, if we meditate merely on bindu and ashe, then that is
completion stage practice that is not profound. Creation stage
practice becomes profound when we connect it with meditating on
bindu and ashe. Completion stage practice becomes profound
when we meditate on the true nature of mind, which is bliss and
emptiness.
Eleventh verse of Lucky:
The fruit of this creation and completion must ripen at the
appropriate time, but this depends on your pure vision of your vajra
brothers and sisters. It must increase. If pure vision dawns in your
mind, this is what it means to be lucky. How can pure vision
dawn in a practitioner's mind? Pure vision arises when the
practitioner knows: that whatever appears is just of the
nature of appearance and emptiness, undifferentiable, that all the
appearances of the outer physical environment, whatever they might
be, are the same in that they are just appearance-emptiness,
undifferentiable, that the physical forms of all the beings in the
environment are appearance-emptiness, undifferentiable, that the
minds of all sentient beings are of the nature of clarity and
emptiness, undifferentiable. Knowing these things causes pure
vision to arise and when that pure vision arises, then that is what
it means to be lucky.
In short, all the appearances of this life are just like a dream.
They are just like the moon's reflection on a pool of water.
They are just like a rainbow. The mind is radiant
clarity. It is clarity and emptiness undifferentiable.
When we realize these two things, the nature of appearances and the
nature of mind, pure vision arises. The reason for this is
that when we realize that appearances are just appearance-emptiness
undifferentiable, how could it be possible that any one appearance
would be impure or that there could be something wrong with it,
because it is all just appearance-emptiness. So the absence of
any more thoughts of something being impure prevents any type of
wrong thought occurring, because we view everything to be just pure
appearance-emptiness, and that is what pure vision or sacred vision
is all about.
With regard to our own minds and the minds of others, we come to
understand that the mind's basic nature is clarity-emptiness,
undifferentiable, and is completely free from any stains.
Thoughts may be confused conceptual mental activity, but this mental
conceptual activity doesn't really exist. When we know that, there
is no way to be judgmental about the minds of others, and pure
vision with regard to mind arises as well.
Twelth and thirteenth verses of Lucky:
Another reason you might be lucky– The freedoms and
resources, this excellent base Is hard to find, and what's
harder than that Is using it to practice Dharma correctly So
if you are on the path of correct practice– This is what it
means to be lucky.
Knowing what it means to be lucky Day and night, without
distraction In order to accomplish great benefit For the
teachings and for all beings May all of us practice The
Dharma of the lucky ones.
This last verse is Rinpoche's aspiration. Knowing what it means
to be lucky day and night without distraction in order to accomplish
great benefit for the teachings and for all beings, may all of us
practice the dharma of the lucky ones.
This talk was given on September 11, 1998, to the Nalandabodhi
and Karma Thekchen Choling sanghas in Vancouver, B.C.,
Canada.
4 of 4 | 1, 2 , 3, 4 | Talk
Index |